Great article! I so appreciate your objective, first principles approach here--as against taking a pro- or anti-car general attitude.
You mention the Netherlands at the end. That in my mind raises the question of the role of bicycles. The single most striking thing when visiting that country is the hundreds of bicycles everywhere--the bike parking garages near train stations, the bike pathways that enable safe commutes, and just the presence of bikes everywhere.
I’m in the US, where heat, hills, and spread-out suburbs make biking as transportation less viable. But what about e-bikes? An e-bike is a legitimate single-modal transportation tool for distance up to maybe 15 or so km (10 miles). In many European and US East Coast cities, combined with good bike infrastructure they could take many cars off the streets. Even in a place like LA with its multi-center, car-centric development, 10 miles takes you from many neighborhoods to their local shopping areas, schools, and civic infrastructure. Right now, hardly anyone bikes here (biking is for exercise, not for transport) yet I think e-bikes, if we fully embraced them, could change that. They already are growing popular with young people: my kids’ high school this year installed e-bike parking and I’d guess about 10-15% of kids ride bikes now, reducing the drop-off car traffic jam considerably.
Good post and I totally agree. The Netherlands is great because they have good solutions for cars, bicycles - e-bikes included - and trains and trams. The more transport the better for serving people’s demands and enabling value adding commerce.
Interesting series of essays! I wanted to respond to a point. From what I understand, tunnelling a road is going to be a lot less cost-effective than tunnelling a train every time. A train can do 32000+ people per hour per direction and a road lane can do 2000 pphpd. If the problem is a capacity constraint and the demand is along a line that can be served by a train, a road tunnel is not going to look good on a cost-benefit analysis
This is before considering ventilation requirements for internal combustion cars and trucks
This is why it’s important to analyse at the level of the whole network. While a road tunnel may not be able to fit as many people through it as a rail tunnel, you have to see them as a tiny part of a much larger network. People may be so widely distributed that they won’t actually use the train but they will use the tunnelled road.
Which is why I propose a different standard than cost benefit analysis: does it cost anything. I think we could fund all of the worthwhile road tunnels with tolls or other charges.
It seems like you've mentioned "Baldwin." Are you referring to a specific person, place, concept, or something else? Please provide more https://cotonmode.co.uk/collections/cushions-seat-pads context so I can assist you accurately!
It seems like you might be referring to "Baldwin," but the context is unclear. "Baldwin" could refer to a variety of things including a surname, a place, a company, or a product. If you could provide more context or specify https://carxstreetapkk.com/carx-street-for-android/ which "Baldwin" you are referring to, I could give you more detailed information tailored to your needs.
Addressing road maintenance and infrastructure needs is essential for ensuring the safety, mobility, and economic vitality of communities. Investing in road repairs, maintenance, and upgrades can help mitigate these negative impacts and create safer and more efficient transportation networks for all. https://apkstrip.com/dragon-city-mod-apk/
To address these issues, governments and local authorities need to prioritize road maintenance and invest in infrastructure improvements. This includes regular inspections, repairs, and upgrades to ensure that roads are safe, smooth, and accessible for all road users. Additionally, promoting alternative modes of transportation, such as cycling and public transit, can help reduce congestion and alleviate pressure on road networks. https://bikesninja.com/
Great article! I so appreciate your objective, first principles approach here--as against taking a pro- or anti-car general attitude.
You mention the Netherlands at the end. That in my mind raises the question of the role of bicycles. The single most striking thing when visiting that country is the hundreds of bicycles everywhere--the bike parking garages near train stations, the bike pathways that enable safe commutes, and just the presence of bikes everywhere.
I’m in the US, where heat, hills, and spread-out suburbs make biking as transportation less viable. But what about e-bikes? An e-bike is a legitimate single-modal transportation tool for distance up to maybe 15 or so km (10 miles). In many European and US East Coast cities, combined with good bike infrastructure they could take many cars off the streets. Even in a place like LA with its multi-center, car-centric development, 10 miles takes you from many neighborhoods to their local shopping areas, schools, and civic infrastructure. Right now, hardly anyone bikes here (biking is for exercise, not for transport) yet I think e-bikes, if we fully embraced them, could change that. They already are growing popular with young people: my kids’ high school this year installed e-bike parking and I’d guess about 10-15% of kids ride bikes now, reducing the drop-off car traffic jam considerably.
I wrote about e-bikes and some of their potential here: https://open.substack.com/pub/heikelarson/p/e-bikes-cool-tools-with-hot-benefits
I just love how many different people choose e-bikes and wish we’d fine a way to use this new tool to make our cities more like Amsterdam.
Good post and I totally agree. The Netherlands is great because they have good solutions for cars, bicycles - e-bikes included - and trains and trams. The more transport the better for serving people’s demands and enabling value adding commerce.
Interesting series of essays! I wanted to respond to a point. From what I understand, tunnelling a road is going to be a lot less cost-effective than tunnelling a train every time. A train can do 32000+ people per hour per direction and a road lane can do 2000 pphpd. If the problem is a capacity constraint and the demand is along a line that can be served by a train, a road tunnel is not going to look good on a cost-benefit analysis
This is before considering ventilation requirements for internal combustion cars and trucks
This is why it’s important to analyse at the level of the whole network. While a road tunnel may not be able to fit as many people through it as a rail tunnel, you have to see them as a tiny part of a much larger network. People may be so widely distributed that they won’t actually use the train but they will use the tunnelled road.
Which is why I propose a different standard than cost benefit analysis: does it cost anything. I think we could fund all of the worthwhile road tunnels with tolls or other charges.
It seems like you've mentioned "Baldwin." Are you referring to a specific person, place, concept, or something else? Please provide more https://cotonmode.co.uk/collections/cushions-seat-pads context so I can assist you accurately!
It seems like you might be referring to "Baldwin," but the context is unclear. "Baldwin" could refer to a variety of things including a surname, a place, a company, or a product. If you could provide more context or specify https://carxstreetapkk.com/carx-street-for-android/ which "Baldwin" you are referring to, I could give you more detailed information tailored to your needs.
Addressing road maintenance and infrastructure needs is essential for ensuring the safety, mobility, and economic vitality of communities. Investing in road repairs, maintenance, and upgrades can help mitigate these negative impacts and create safer and more efficient transportation networks for all. https://apkstrip.com/dragon-city-mod-apk/
To address these issues, governments and local authorities need to prioritize road maintenance and invest in infrastructure improvements. This includes regular inspections, repairs, and upgrades to ensure that roads are safe, smooth, and accessible for all road users. Additionally, promoting alternative modes of transportation, such as cycling and public transit, can help reduce congestion and alleviate pressure on road networks. https://bikesninja.com/